Border Quarrel

A cause that is made
Two nations whose lands touch have no cause for war just because they touch. A master who wants one makes it: his patrols cross, men die, and he says the other side killed them. That is a border quarrel. It costs quarrel stir influence influence. Not against an ally, a rebel nation, or a nation he is already at war with, and only where the two lands touch. A servant nation may stir a border, and a servant nation's border may be stirred.

The other nation answers at once
- Send men to the border — spends quarrel guard manpower from the levy. The quarrel ends. The two think quarrel guarded opinion penalty of each other, and the army at home stands taller.
- Pay blood money — quarrel blood money per town for each town it holds, paid to the stirrer. The quarrel ends. Its army is shamed, as when tribute is paid.
- Take the blame — free. The quarrel ends. Its army is shamed more, and its town nearest the stirrer grows angry.
- Show the nations the lie — for quarrel show lie influence influence through an embassy in the stirrer's court, or twice that without one. An AI master of below-neutral trust shows it when he has an embassy there; without one, only a master whose trust is under 0.3 does. The quarrel ends. The stirrer carries the deed Forged A Cause, every nation that knows him thinks quarrel lie shown opinion penalty of him, and he can never stir that border again.
- Do nothing — the quarrel stands.

Unanswered, it ripens
After quarrel ripen turns turns a standing quarrel becomes the cause Border Dispute, and the stirrer may declare a limited war on it. An AI stirrer at least as strong as the victim marches on it the day it ripens. A ripe quarrel lowers the stirrer's war bar against the victim (AIWarEvaluator.War ripe quarrel delta, 0.2), and lifts the AI's limit on wars at once for that one target, as a betrayal or seized cargo does. Each nation that knows the stirrer and trusts little does not believe him and thinks quarrel doubt opinion penalty of him. The cause is spent when the two go to war. After a quarrel ends, the same border cannot be stirred again for quarrel cooldown turns turns.

Who does it
The player, from the diplomacy window. An AI master does it when he is strong enough to want a war, has no cause, and is land-hungry (expansion at or above the middle); see Reason for War. A master who is not sly, and not land-hungry, stirs one too when he can, before he asks a tribute. If his quarrel with that nation is already running, he presses it instead: it ripens 3 turns sooner (AIDeniedWarRoads). An AI victim answers from its master's character: one of below-neutral trust shows the lie if he can (without an embassy, only one of trust under 0.3); a proud one, or one who is not badly outmatched, sends men, and stands firm when he has none to send; a meek one facing a neighbour at least 1 times as strong pays, or takes the blame when he is tight-fisted or poor. No dice.

What everyone sees
Every nation that has met the stirrer hears of the deaths, of the answer, and of the day the quarrel becomes a cause. The player is asked in a popup when it is done to him.

Measured (headless sim, seeds 9 / 6 / 2, one run each to the game's end, turns 497 / 486 / 492): quarrels met with men 7 / 5 / 6; taken the blame for 1 / 0 / 0; paid off 0 / 0 / 1; shown to be a lie 1 / 1 / 1; left unanswered 0 / 3 / 0; ripened into a cause 0 / 2 / 0; wars declared on it 0 / 1 / 0. Most victims answer, so a war from a border quarrel is rare. Most wars still begin from a refused demand to kneel (108 / 153 / 82).

What it does NOT do
No land changes hands in a quarrel. No one is forced into war: a ripe cause is only a cause. A quarrel never starts by chance.

The borrowed quarrel
A nation that keeps a messenger in a court can lend that nation a quarrel with its neighbour: the messenger reports that the neighbour's riders cut down its patrols. It costs proxy quarrel influence. An aggressive court, or one that already dislikes the neighbour, takes it up, and it runs as an ordinary quarrel from that nation; otherwise the messenger is turned away and the influence is lost. If the neighbour shows the lie, the lender, not the court it fooled, is marked forged a cause and shamed; both neighbours think proxy hand shown opinion worse of it, and its messenger is sent home. An AI master who wants a war on a nation it does not touch reaches for this road. A lent quarrel that is taken up also counts as a push by the lender toward the neighbour's collapse (Nation Collapse and Successor States).

Ears in their nation
A victim with a few ears in the stirrer's court (Spies in a Rival Court) shows the lie at the base price, as if it kept an embassy there, and an AI victim weighs showing it as it would with an embassy.

How it connects

See also

Tags

Home