Reason for War

A reason for war is a fair excuse for declaring war on another nation.

Unjustified War
Declaring war without a reason for war is considered unjustified. The warmongering penalty spreads to ALL known nations — not just the target. Every nation that has discovered you will lower their opinion of you.

A war with no cause is also judged at home, and remembered. The nation carries the mark went to war for nothing: the peasants lose 4 favor (their men are sent off for nothing), the merchants 2 (trade stops for nothing), the army 4 (soldiers die with no cause to name). Foreign masters who have met you may hear of it (word of a war for nothing) and bring it up in talks, where they can ask for an apology. The news itself costs no more opinion abroad: the warmongering penalty already paid that. A war WITH a cause leaves no mark. An ally pulled in by a pact is not marked: it did not choose the war. Measured (headless sim, seeds 9 / 6 / 2, one run each to the end, turns 509 / 424 / 467): marks 15 / 16 / 13, news heard 14 / 13 / 13.

Few nations march for nothing
An AI nation looks for a cause before it marches. With none, a mild or even-tempered master (aggression under 0.6) does not go to war at all. A hard one still may, but only with a far bigger army than a war with a cause would need: one more whole strength ratio, less for the hardest nations (AIWarEvaluator.No cause bar). A war that comes from nothing is meant to be the rare one.
A province that breaks away from its nation goes to war on the rebels' cause (Rebellion Suppression), the same one a rebel nation opens with, so a war of independence is not counted as a war for nothing and does not set the whole world against the newborn nation.

A nation denied its war
An AI master strong enough to want a war, and held back only because he has no cause, does not sit still (AIDeniedWarRoads). A land-hungry master whose land touches his rival's stirs a quarrel on the border and waits for it to ripen into a cause (see Border Quarrel). Otherwise a master who trusts no one pays his rival's rebels: the standing subsidy if the rival has a rising, else the plot against its nation. Any other master stirs a border quarrel if he can, else pays the rebels, and only then demands tribute; a master whose quarrel already runs presses it nearer. Each takes another road when his own is closed. He rolls no die for it.

Touching lands are not a cause
Border Dispute is held only by a nation whose border quarrel has ripened. Two nations whose lands touch have no cause against each other until one of them makes it.

Demand Tribute
Any nation, the player's too, may tell a nation it has met to pay: tribute money per town for each town the other holds, for tribute demand influence influence. Not an ally, not a servant nation, not a nation it is at war with. The other pays when it has the money and the demander is strong enough for its master's pride — tribute pay ratio meek times its strength for the meekest, tribute pay ratio proud for the proudest. A nation already at war with anyone needs tribute second front relief less of a gap (never below the meekest's): it would rather pay than open a second front. If it pays, the money moves, the two think tribute paid opinion penalty of each other, and no new demand may be sent for tribute demand cooldown turns turns. If it refuses, the two think tribute refused opinion penalty of each other and the demander holds the cause Refused Tribute: penalty reduction 30, a limited war only. One refusal ends the asking. Every nation that knows the demander thinks tribute bully opinion penalty of it either way, and all who have met them hear what was asked and what was answered. At home the army of the nation that paid is shamed, and the army of a nation that refused stands taller. It is a thin cause and the nations know it.
The Danegeld: a nation that pays is remembered as one who pays (Nation.Tributes paid). Every later demand asks 15 more for each tribute it paid, and an AI master who is not soft (aggression at least neutral) comes for tribute from any nation it has met that is known to pay, when it would be paid (AIDanegeld). The way out is through: a master of at least middling pride pays no more after 3 tributes, whatever the threat; and at peace, a payer that came out of a war level or ahead (no less harm done than taken) of a nation that had demanded tribute of it, or that refused it and was not beaten back (no less harm done than taken), sheds the name, and every nation hears of it. Paying stamps no mark; submission is not cruelty.
Measured (headless sim, seeds 9 / 6 / 2, 400 turns): wars wanted with no cause 51 / 50 / 85; tribute demanded by such a master 15 / 26 / 21, refused 14 / 25 / 15, paid 1 / 1 / 6; wars declared over refused tribute 6 / 13 / 10; rebels paid instead 0 / 0 / 19.

Penalty Reduction
The penalty formula is base × (100 − penalty reduction) ÷ 100 (whole-number, rounded toward zero), where penalty reduction is a 0–100 strength rating on the reason for war. A reduction of 100 removes the warmongering penalty entirely (e.g. defensive war), 70 cuts it to under a third, and 0 leaves the full base penalty. On a justified war the penalty is only applied when it is still negative, so a reduction that cancels it causes no opinion loss. Declaring the war still spends the normal action Influence.

The War Footing Waiver
One law switches the whole reputation hit off. While War Footing is in force the reason for war is still recorded, but the warmongering penalty is skipped entirely — justified war and unjustified war alike. The world stops crying about your wars.

Total War Unlock
Stronger justifications also unlock the option for Total War posture.

Causes and messengers
A nation may hold a cause while its messengers remain at court. Actually declaring war closes both directional embassies through the War Posture declaration flow, with or without a cause. The cause changes justification and the allowed posture; it does not expel messengers by being held. An embassy can also let its owner lend a Border Quarrel, or lower the price of showing a quarrel's lie before it becomes a Border Dispute cause. Those existing choices and their cause live under Border Quarrel.

Reason for War are earned through game events — border disputes, broken treaties, attacks on your territory, or other provocations by the target nation.

Against the Butcher. Every nation that has met a doer of a cruel deed (any mark in Marks.Cruelties, stamped within butcher memory turns) may march against it with a cause: penalty reduction 60, and it allows Total War. The Broken Oath. A nation whose Bound ally broke the alliance holds a cause against that ally for the rest of the game: penalty reduction 60, Total War allowed. It also lowers the AI's war bar against the betrayer. The Broken Treaty. A nation whose partner narrowed a sworn trade road before its term holds a cause against it for trade treaty grievance turns: penalty reduction 40, no Total War. The Lost Lands. A nation may march to take back towns that were taken from it (Town.Taken from path), while the taker still holds one: penalty reduction 70, a limited war. Both also lower the AI's war bar against the target (AIWarEvaluator.Grievance for), scaled by the master's aggression, so a neighbour actually steps in rather than only holding the excuse.

Condemned by the Congress. When the World Congress votes to condemn a nation (see The World Congress), every member that has met it holds this cause for congress condemn turns: penalty reduction 80. It outweighs Against the Butcher, because the world's leave counts for more than one nation's charge.

Break the Chains. A nation holding people in chains gives a cause to their own nation at once, to its neighbours from the Middle Age, and to every nation that has met it from the Middle Age (Liberation.Grounds hold): penalty reduction 70, no end date while the chains stand. It vanishes once the holder frees them all. Any war against the holder by a nation that holds this cause counts: a town taken in it frees its chains for the liberator, and a peace that finds the holder losing frees every chain it holds (see Chains).

Measured
Headless sim, seeds 9 / 6 / 2, one run each to the game's end (turns 429 / 433 / 543): wars declared with no cause 28 / 12 / 23 of 344 / 222 / 381 (8 / 5 / 6 in 100). Before the cause rule they were 74 / 78 / 80 of 316 / 261 / 223. The wars did not get fewer; they got reasons — refused service, ore claims and the rebels' cause carry most of them.

They Would Remake Us: a nation whose people are being turned by a neighbour's creed may make war on that neighbour, and a lost war of this kind shakes the loser's creed (see Whose World Wins).

How it connects

See also

Tags

Home