The Weight of a Losing War — who is winning, and what losing costs
A war is not a count of battles. Each side keeps a tally of the harm it has done the other: towns taken, farms and mines burned, turns an enemy town starved under siege, caravans and supply trains raided, companies cut down. Harm done minus harm taken is where a nation stands.
Four standings
A nation well ahead is winning. Close to even it is holding. Well behind it is bleeding, and far behind it is beaten. A nation at war with several enemies is judged by its worst war.
Losing is felt at home
While a nation is bleeding or beaten, every one of its towns grows more restless each turn, more so when beaten. A nation losing a war it started itself hurts most: the people were promised a short war. A beaten nation also looks weaker to every neighbour weighing whether to fall on it.
The white flag
A nation beaten for several turns in a row sues for peace. It offers a price: towns nearest the winner's seat (never its capital), or to kneel as the winner's servant nation when it is small enough. The winner may take it — the war ends, the price is paid, the winner gains influence for the victory, and the whole world hears of it — or send the messenger back. A human winner is asked; an AI winner takes the peace unless its master loves war. A human losing a war can also sue for peace from the diplomacy panel, which says in words how the war stands, and pick the price. A nation that holds nothing but its capital cannot pay in towns.
Returning to a war
Saving keeps both sides' harm, beaten turns, refused surrenders, who declared, and the last harm and refused-peace turns. Returning to that war keeps those facts. Saving is neither peace nor a fresh war. A war also keeps whether the declarer had creed-war grounds at its start; its public name does not decide what defeat does to belief.
A nation sent home empty-handed
A beaten nation whose surrender is refused does not crawl back on a timetable. Each refusal makes it wait longer before it asks that enemy again, and its pride decides when it stops asking at all: a war-loving nation refused once fights to the end; a meek one swallows its pride and asks again, up to a few times. A new war, or peace, wipes the count.
A refused surrender is remembered
Sending a white flag back costs the refuser opinion with every nation it has met, and neighbouring nations may name it a nation that will not stop.
Vultures circle
A nation that is bleeding or beaten in one war looks weak to everyone else. A bold master (aggression above the middle) finds war on it easier (AIWarEvaluator.Is losing another war, war vulture delta), so a nation losing on one front often finds a second enemy at its back. An ally never piles on: allies cannot declare war on each other. The vulture is remembered: it carries the mark picked over the fallen, which nations carry by gossip and a master can demand an apology for; the nation it struck thinks vulture grudge opinion less of it; and every nation that knows the victim hears who came for the carcass.
Peace with no price
A master also offers peace as things stand, with nothing paid, in two cases. His nation is failing at home (see Troubles at Home). Or the war has run long and he is not winning it: a meek master tires after a few dozen turns, a war-loving one fights three times as long. The enemy is asked. A human is asked in a popup. An AI master takes the peace when his own nation is failing, or when he is not winning and does not love war. A master who is winning and sound at home sends the messenger back, and nobody asks again for some turns. A third case: a war nobody is fighting. Every open war costs influence each turn, so when neither side has done the other harm for a while (war idle turns meek 15 for a meek master, war idle turns proud 40 for a war-loving one) a master who is not winning offers peace, and the other side takes it even when it is winning, unless it loves war.
When the winner is away
A human who is not at the table gets a peace offer or a surrender as a letter that never runs out; the human must answer it before the turn can end. A no on the letter is a refusal at the full price: a peace offer starts its wait again, and a surrender turned away is remembered by the war and by the nations that know the winner.
What it does NOT do
A nation sworn as the Ratti's blade (The Hidden Hands) can neither sue for peace nor be offered or granted one until its oath runs out, however the war stands.
It never ends a war on its own: someone has to sue and someone has to accept. Harm done before the war, or after the peace, does not count. Peace wipes both tallies, so a new war starts at even. Allies of the beaten nation are not bound by its surrender; each pair makes its own peace. Holding is never punished.
Measured
Headless sim, seeds 9 / 6 / 2, one run each to the game's end (turns 530 / 465 / 463): wars ended by surrender 20 / 5 / 14, surrenders refused 17 / 9 / 11, average surrendered war 92 / 125 / 89 turns.
A surrender is not an honourable peace. The peace itself still fires, but the nation that sued is also remembered for folly (sued for peace credits Fool 3 in leader legacy tracker) and its Military loses surrender military favor on top of the peace hit. An ally still at war with the winner thinks separate peace ally opinion less of a nation that surrendered alone. The Military's turn check counts a war standing of bleeding or beaten as a losing war, not just lost battles.
