The harvest failed twice. The trials made sure something else did too. After a hard year the people need a reason, and a reason is a face.
When it is offered
Only after a real hardship in the town (people lost to hunger, famine or plague, a starving siege, a dark age over the nation, a disaster that struck the nation lately, or a sky that has gone wrong in the dim years), only while the town is stirring or worse, and not again for a long while after. Rebels are never offered it.
The answers
Hold the trials: the anger goes out of the town at once. The nation carries bled your own people, the town is scarred, and it stays afraid for two ages: it grows no Land while afraid (Land is where its scholars are kept for now). If the town holds strangers, the trials name them: their own nation is told, and they are driven out — unless the town already knows whom to blame.
Whom the hunger blames
A famine the nation made — its own soldiers emptied the barns, or its grain ships sailed while the town starved — is laid at the nation's door: the Peasants think less of it the moment the town asks for a name, and the trials, if held, drive out no strangers. A famine is remembered only for a short while, and only by the nation it happened under: a town that changes hands does not blame its new nation for the old one's levy. A town starved by a siege names the enemy at the gate (unless that enemy now holds it): its nation thinks worse of the besieger, and the trials drive out no strangers either. A town the land struck while it was warned of the blow and the nation did not ready it lays that year at the nation's door the same way: the Peasants think less of it, and the trials drive out no strangers. A new nation is not blamed for the old one's neglect. Any other hard year falls on the strangers, as it always did.
The nation answers for it: it costs influence, the estate behind the nation thinks it weak, the Peasants respect it, and the town calms only a little. Nobody dies, and nothing is remembered.
Let it pass: nothing. The anger keeps climbing.
The habit
A town still afraid that meets another hard year lights the fires without waiting. The nation can stop it (influence, and the Peasants hate being stopped) or let it burn: the trials again, a second scar.
What the world hears
Met nations hear of trials and may name the nation. The deed opens Against the Butcher.
What it does not do
It never names a real-world people; the crowd names the odd, the alone and the strangers. It shows no meter: a feared town is only a town that watches its neighbours.
