A trade road is not only open or shut. Two nations decide how wide the gate stands.
A toll road
Every road begins as a toll road. The nation keeps its guards and its tolls, and the road pays the plain route income.
An open road
The tolls come off. More carts pass, so the road pays more. With the goods come the craftsmen's ways: a partner a age ahead of you teaches you down an open road, just as an import from it would. The Merchants of both nations warm to it, now and then.
A free road
No toll, no guard, no question asked. It pays the most and teaches the same. But foreign goods are cheap, and the weavers and smiths at home cannot sell at that price: the Peasants lose favor to a free road now and then, and they say so.
Widening and narrowing
A road widens one step at a time, and only when BOTH nations think well enough of each other. A master who loves trade asks less of his partner before he opens the gate. Either nation may narrow the road one step at any time; the other takes it as a wound, and its Merchants curse the name of the nation that did it. Closing a road and opening it again starts it as a toll road.
A sworn road
Widening a road swears a treaty: the road stays that wide for trade treaty term turns. A nation that narrows it before the term is out breaks the treaty. The partner thinks trade treaty broken opinion penalty less of it on top of the narrowing, the breaker carries the deed broke a trade treaty, which gossip carries to far nations, and the wronged nation holds The Broken Treaty as a cause for war for trade treaty grievance turns. A master whose word is worth something to him will not shut a sworn road early; a faithless one will.
A squeezed road
The nation that keeps its tolls at the gate AND taxes the market town high takes too much. The merchants go round the gates by night: part of the road's money never reaches the treasury, and the Merchants sour on the nation now and then. Lower the town's tax or open the road wider, and the carts come back to the gate.
What it does NOT do
A grade does nothing while the road is silent — at war, under a trade ban, or past a nation's limit of roads. It does not carry plague or faith yet; those ride the roads when the world has them. People already ride it: a wider gate carries more families toward the richer town (see People Follow the Carts).
